Skip to main content

Illegalization of Abortion

Here’s my argument for why I think that the illegalization of abortion is philosophically problematic:

(P1) x is a human just in case x has a genetic code that is distinctively human.

(P2) A fetus, at some point in the fetal development, acquires a genetic code that is distinctively human.

(P3) So, at a certain point in the fetal development, a fetus becomes a bona fide human.

(P4) From a legal standpoint, the right to life of a human is protected by the law.

(P5) There is no characterization of a human that can objectively identify its instantiations other than the mere possession of a distinctively human genetic code.

(P6) So, a fetus, at a certain point in the fetal development, has the right to life that is protected by the law.

(P7) However, Judith Jarvis Thomson presents an argument that persuasively proves that the fact that the fetus has the right to life does not necessarily entail that it has the right to use the mother’s body.

(C) Therefore, even if a fetus has the right to life that is protected by the law, it’s not clear how such a fact can sufficiently justify the legal prohibition of abortion.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Divine-Human Love Affairs

Since Valentine’s Day is right around the corner, let me briefly reflect about love. What is the nature of God’s love for humanity? What is the nature of that love that has God as its object or the kind of love (directed to God) that the Bible demands from humans? God’s love and the love that is demanded from us are both intense and radical. God’s love for humanity is both intense and radical. Based on the theological narrative that developed through the spiritual insights of the early followers of Jesus (like Peter, John, and Paul), Jesus is the ultimate expression of God’s love for humanity. What does it mean? According to their theological narrative, Jesus is the only begotten Son of God. God sent his only begotten Son to serve as the sacrifice for the sins of the world. The religious frameworks of the ancient world, of course, shaped the formation of this narrative. In the ancient world, human actions that offend the deities require sacrifices that sufficiently appease the offended...
Post a Comment
Read more

Politicization of the Pulpit

After the death of Jerry Falwell and the declining popularity of Pat Robertson, surprisingly the legacy of the evangelical right persists in politically conservative media (like Fox News) and conservative evangelical churches (like some Southern Baptist and Assemblies of God churches). Equipped with sensationalistic jesters and political preachers, bearers of such legacy can pester the current administration. No wonder Obama and his advisers are launching an attack on Fox News, the main source of information for the evangelical right. Since the presidential campaign season for the 2008 election, I heard numerous anti-Obama sermons in a large congregation with a devoutly Republican pastor. A devoutly Republican pastor is one who cleverly subsumes the Christian message under the Republican agendas. Many conservative evangelical churches have devoutly Republican pastors, who regularly politicize the pulpit by unnecessarily turning congregants against Obama. In a subtle way, this is danger...
2 comments
Read more